In this guide13 sections
- Key takeaways
- What counts as serious and willful misconduct
- Whose misconduct counts
- Safety order violations and Cal/OSHA evidence
- Examples that can support an S&W claim
- How much the increase is worth
- Can your benefits be cut for your own misconduct?
- Deadlines
- How the petition works
- S&W petition or a civil lawsuit
- What to do now
- Frequently asked questions
- Talk to a California workers’ comp lawyer
In California, when a work injury is caused by your employer’s serious and willful misconduct, the workers’ compensation you are otherwise owed is increased by one-half, plus up to $250 in costs and expenses (Labor Code §4553). You don’t file a separate lawsuit to get it. You ask the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) for the increase in your workers’ comp case, and you generally have 12 months from the date of injury to do it (Labor Code §5407).
Key takeaways
- A serious and willful misconduct (S&W) finding increases your workers’ comp compensation by 50%, plus up to $250 in costs and expenses.
- The bar is high: the employer or a managing representative must have known about the danger (or it was obvious) and failed to correct it with reckless disregard for workers’ safety.
- The deadline is 12 months from the date of injury, and it isn’t extended because you are receiving benefits or already filed your regular claim.
- The employer pays the increase itself; California bars insurers from insuring it (Insurance Code §11661).
- An S&W petition is part of your comp case, not a lawsuit. Suing your employer is allowed only in narrow situations (Labor Code §§3602(b), 4558, 3706).
What counts as serious and willful misconduct
California workers’ comp is a no-fault system. You get medical care, temporary disability and permanent disability benefits whether or not anyone was careless. An S&W claim is the exception: the one place in the comp system where the employer’s fault changes how much you receive.
Ordinary carelessness is not enough, and even poor safety practices may not qualify. In general, the WCAB looks for conduct showing that the employer:
- knew about a dangerous condition, or the danger was obvious;
- knew, or should have known, that the probable result was serious injury; and
- deliberately failed to take reasonable steps to fix it, showing reckless disregard for workers’ safety.
Think of it as the difference between a mistake and a choice. A machine guard that breaks without warning is usually an accident. A guard that management removed to speed up production, after workers complained, is the kind of fact pattern S&W claims are built on.
Whose misconduct counts
Labor Code §4553 applies only when the misconduct is by the employer itself or by certain people who run the business:
| Type of employer | Whose misconduct counts |
|---|---|
| Any employer | The employer, or its managing representative |
| Partnership | A partner, or a managing representative or general superintendent |
| Corporation | An executive, managing officer or general superintendent |
A careless coworker, or a front-line lead who isn’t a managing representative, usually isn’t enough by itself. The evidence has to tie the decision, or the knowing failure to act, to someone the statute lists. That often means internal emails, safety meeting notes, prior complaints and witness testimony.
Safety order violations and Cal/OSHA evidence
Many S&W claims rest on a Cal/OSHA safety order violation, such as rules on machine guarding, lockout/tagout, fall protection, trenching or confined spaces. When the claim is based on a safety order, Labor Code §4553.1 requires the WCAB to specifically find:
- How the order was violated, in specific terms.
- Causation: that the violation proximately caused the injury or death, and how.
- Knowledge or reckless disregard: either the safety order and the conditions that made it apply were known to and violated by a particular named person (the employer or a manager listed in §4553), or the condition was obvious, created a probability of serious injury, and the failure to correct it showed reckless disregard for the probable consequences.
If Cal/OSHA inspected after your injury, its file can be valuable: inspection notes, photographs, interview summaries and any earlier citations for the same hazard. Under Labor Code §6304.5, a Cal/OSHA citation generally can’t be used as evidence in a personal injury case, but that rule has an exception for cases between an employee and their own employer. A citation helps but isn’t required, and it doesn’t automatically prove S&W, because Cal/OSHA’s “serious” and “willful” labels are workplace safety categories, not the WCAB’s test.
If a hazard is still there, you can file a workplace safety complaint with Cal/OSHA. Cal/OSHA doesn’t inspect every injury, so preserve your own evidence early.
Examples that can support an S&W claim
Every case turns on its facts, but these situations come up often in serious injuries, including crush injuries and amputations:
- Removing or disabling a machine guard, interlock or emergency stop to keep production moving.
- Telling workers to skip lockout/tagout before clearing a jam or servicing equipment.
- Sending workers onto a roof, scaffold or lift without fall protection after the hazard was pointed out.
- Ignoring repeated reports of electrical shocks, gas leaks or failing brakes.
- Keeping a hazard in place after a prior citation, near miss or earlier injury from the same condition.
- Putting untrained workers on dangerous equipment knowing they had no training.
What usually doesn’t qualify: a one-time accident with no warning signs, a hazard management didn’t know about and had no reason to know about, or a coworker’s own mistake.
How much the increase is worth
Section 4553 increases “the amount of compensation otherwise recoverable” by one-half, plus costs and expenses up to $250. Labor Code §3207 defines “compensation” broadly as every benefit or payment the workers’ comp laws provide. In practice, the increase is figured on the benefits in your case, such as temporary disability, permanent disability or death benefits. Exactly which items go into the calculation can be disputed, so have the math checked.
Example (hypothetical, simplified): Maria’s hand is crushed when a press with its guard removed cycles unexpectedly. Assume the compensation in her case totals $60,000. If the WCAB finds S&W, the increase is $30,000, plus up to $250 in costs and expenses.
- The employer pays, not the insurer. Insurance Code §11661 bars insurers from insuring the S&W increase, though an insurer may cover the cost of defending the claim. That is one reason employers fight these claims hard.
- It is still workers’ comp. The increase doesn’t add pain and suffering or punitive damages.
- Related rule: Labor Code §4557 increases compensation by 50% when an employee under 16 was illegally employed when hurt, with some exceptions.
Can your benefits be cut for your own misconduct?
The rule runs both ways. Under Labor Code §4551, if the injury was caused by the worker’s own serious and willful misconduct, compensation is reduced by one-half. The reduction doesn’t apply when the injury results in death, causes permanent disability of 70% or more, was caused by the employer’s failure to follow a safety law or Cal/OSHA order, or the worker was under 16. The reduction isn’t valid until the WCAB decides the issue (Labor Code §4552); an adjuster can’t simply cut your checks in half.
Deadlines
| Claim | Deadline | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Employer’s serious and willful misconduct | 12 months from the date of injury; not extended by payment of benefits, an agreement to pay or filing your regular claim | Labor Code §5407 |
| Regular medical and disability benefits | Generally one year from the date of injury, or from the last benefit paid or provided | Labor Code §5405 |
| New and further disability | Within five years of the date of injury; does not extend the S&W deadline | Labor Code §5410 |
Because the S&W deadline runs from the injury date, a worker still in treatment and still receiving checks can lose the claim without realizing it.
How the petition works
- Open a WCAB case by filing an Application for Adjudication of Claim, if one isn’t already on file.
- File the S&W petition with the WCAB and serve the employer and insurer. It should state the hazard, who knew about it, what they did or failed to do, and how it caused the injury.
- Expect the employer to defend separately, often with its own attorney, because it pays the increase.
- Discovery: records, depositions of managers and coworkers, and any Cal/OSHA file.
- Hearing and decision. The claim moves through the WCAB process, which can include a mandatory settlement conference and trial. You must prove it by a preponderance of the evidence (Labor Code §3202.5), not by clear and convincing evidence.
Your regular benefits should keep moving while the S&W issue is litigated.
S&W petition or a civil lawsuit
Workers’ comp is usually your only remedy against your employer (Labor Code §3602), and an S&W petition doesn’t change that. A civil case against the employer is allowed only in narrow situations: a willful physical assault by the employer; fraudulent concealment of the injury and its connection to the job that makes it worse, with damages limited to the aggravation; an employer’s defective product sold to an independent third person; knowing removal of, or failure to install, a manufacturer-required point-of-operation guard on a power press (Labor Code §4558); or an uninsured employer (Labor Code §3706). You may also have a third-party claim against someone other than your employer, such as an equipment manufacturer.
What to do now
- Report the injury in writing and get medical care.
- Write down what you know while it’s fresh: the hazard, who knew, prior complaints, near misses and what managers said.
- Save photos, texts, emails and training records, and the names and phone numbers of coworkers who saw the hazard.
- Find out whether Cal/OSHA was called. The free DWC Information and Assistance Unit can explain WCAB forms.
- Mark the 12-month deadline from your injury date on your calendar, and talk to a lawyer well before it.
Frequently asked questions
Is a serious and willful claim the same as suing my employer?
No. It is a petition in your workers’ comp case. It increases your comp benefits by one-half but adds no pain and suffering damages.
How long do I have to file?
Generally 12 months from the date of injury (Labor Code §5407). Receiving benefits or filing your regular claim doesn’t extend that deadline.
Does the insurance company pay the extra 50%?
No. Insurers can’t insure the S&W increase, so the employer pays it.
Do I need a Cal/OSHA citation to win?
No. A citation can be strong evidence, but S&W can be proven with other evidence, and a citation doesn’t automatically prove it.
Can I be fired for filing an S&W claim?
California law prohibits discrimination against workers for filing a workers’ comp claim. See Labor Code §132a retaliation claims.
Talk to a California workers’ comp lawyer
Employees First Labor Law represents workers exclusively in workers’ compensation and employment cases. We offer free virtual consultations to review whether your employer’s conduct may support a serious and willful claim and how much time you have left. Contact us online or call (310) 853-3461.
This article is general information about California law as of 2026, not legal advice for your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.