Skip to content
¿Prefiere español?Empleados PrimeroAbogados Laborales
¿Prefiere español? Empleados Primero Abogados Laborales
EMPLOYEES FIRST LABOR LAW

Compensation Law

Crushed by Machinery at Work: Sue Outside of Workers’ Comp

If you were crushed by machinery at work in California, you usually can’t sue your own employer, because workers’ compensation is generally your only…

Reviewed by Jonathan P. LaCour, Esq. CEO · Senior Trial Counsel

Updated 6 min read

In this guide10 sections
  1. Key takeaways
  2. Why you usually can’t sue your employer
  3. Third parties you may be able to sue
  4. Limits on suing property owners and hiring companies
  5. When you can sue your employer directly
  6. Workers’ comp compared with a civil lawsuit
  7. How the two cases fit together
  8. Evidence to protect right away
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Talk to a California workers’ comp lawyer

If you were crushed by machinery at work in California, you usually can’t sue your own employer, because workers’ compensation is generally your only remedy against it. But you can often sue someone else whose product or conduct caused the injury, such as the machine’s manufacturer or an outside maintenance company. A few narrow exceptions also allow a lawsuit against the employer itself. A civil case can pay for losses workers’ comp never covers, including pain and suffering.

Key takeaways

  • Workers’ comp is generally the exclusive remedy against your employer (Labor Code §3602), but filing a comp claim doesn’t stop you from suing a third party (Labor Code §3852).
  • Common third-party defendants include machine manufacturers and sellers, maintenance and repair contractors, and other companies working on a shared jobsite.
  • You can sue your employer directly in limited cases, such as a knowingly removed power press guard (Labor Code §4558) or an illegally uninsured employer (Labor Code §3706).
  • A personal injury lawsuit generally must be filed within two years (Code of Civil Procedure §335.1), and claims against a public entity require a written claim within six months.
  • Your employer’s insurer can usually be reimbursed from a third-party recovery, so the two cases need to be coordinated.

Why you usually can’t sue your employer

California’s workers’ comp system is a trade-off. You get benefits without proving fault, and in return your employer is generally shielded from lawsuits over workplace injuries (Labor Code §3602). The same protection usually covers coworkers, unless a coworker injured you through a willful and unprovoked physical act of aggression or while intoxicated (Labor Code §3601).

That shield doesn’t extend to companies that aren’t your employer. That is why the first question after a crush injury is: who else had a hand in this machine or this worksite? For a broader overview, see can I sue outside of workers’ comp?

Third parties you may be able to sue

  • The manufacturer or seller of the machine. A product can be defective because of how it was designed, how it was made, or because it lacked adequate warnings or instructions. A press with no two-hand control, a conveyor with an exposed pinch point, or a safety interlock that fails can support a product claim.
  • Maintenance, repair and installation companies. An outside technician who rewired a safety switch, left a guard off after a repair or installed equipment incorrectly may be responsible.
  • Equipment rental companies. A company that rented out a forklift, lift or compactor with known defects can be a defendant.
  • Other contractors on a shared jobsite. On a construction project, a general contractor or another subcontractor whose crew created the hazard may be liable to you if it isn’t your employer.
  • Property owners. An owner of an unsafe loading dock or site can sometimes be liable, but California law limits these claims (see below).

Limits on suing property owners and hiring companies

When a business hires a contractor, California courts generally presume it handed off responsibility for workplace safety to that contractor. A 2021 California Supreme Court decision described two main exceptions: the hiring company kept control over part of the work and used that control in a way that affirmatively contributed to the injury, or a landowner knew or should have known of a concealed hazard the contractor couldn’t reasonably discover and failed to warn about it (read the opinion). These cases turn on detailed facts about who controlled the work.

Staffing arrangements are another trap. If a staffing agency placed you, the client company that directed your work may also count as your employer. When the companies have a valid agreement and the agency actually carries workers’ comp coverage, both are treated as having secured compensation, which generally blocks a lawsuit against either (Labor Code §3602(d)). See workers’ comp for temp and staffing agency workers.

When you can sue your employer directly

ExceptionWhat it requiresLaw
Power press guardThe employer knowingly removed, or knowingly failed to install, a point-of-operation guard on a power press and specifically authorized that under conditions it knew created a probability of serious injury or death; the manufacturer must have designed, required or specified the guard and made that known to the employerLabor Code §4558
Uninsured employerThe employer illegally failed to carry workers’ comp insuranceLabor Code §3706
Willful physical assaultThe employer intentionally physically attacked youLabor Code §3602(b)(1)
Fraudulent concealmentThe employer hid your injury and its connection to work, making it worse; damages are limited to the aggravationLabor Code §3602(b)(2)
Employer-made productA defective product your employer manufactured and sold to an outside party was later provided for your useLabor Code §3602(b)(3)

Even when none of these apply, an employer whose serious and willful misconduct caused the injury can owe you one-half more in workers’ comp benefits (Labor Code §4553). That claim isn’t a lawsuit, and it must be filed within 12 months of the injury (Labor Code §5407). Learn more about serious and willful misconduct.

Workers’ comp compared with a civil lawsuit

Workers’ compThird-party lawsuit
Must you prove fault?NoYes, or a product defect
Wage lossTwo-thirds of average weekly wages, within 2026 limits of $264.61 to $1,764.11 a weekFull past and future lost earnings
Pain and sufferingNot paidCan be recovered
Medical carePaid by the insurer, subject to its review processPast and future medical costs as damages
Main deadlineGenerally 1 year (Labor Code §5405)Generally 2 years (CCP §335.1)

The temporary disability limits come from the Division of Workers’ Compensation’s 2026 rate announcement. Your comp benefits, including medical care, temporary and permanent disability, and a retraining voucher, are covered in workers’ comp for machinery accidents and our guide to crush injuries at work.

How the two cases fit together

You can pursue workers’ comp and a third-party case at the same time. The employer or its insurer may sue the third party to recover what it paid, or join your case. After the court-approved litigation expenses and attorney’s fees are paid from a judgment, the employer can take a first lien for its comp payments (Labor Code §3856), and it may get a credit against future comp benefits up to the net amount you recover (Labor Code §3858). How these numbers are negotiated can make a large difference in what you keep.

Here is a hypothetical. Ana’s arm is crushed in a baler at a recycling plant after a technician from an outside service company disabled the door interlock to stop false alarms. She receives workers’ comp from her employer’s insurer. She may also have a negligence claim against the service company and a product claim against the baler’s manufacturer if the interlock was easy to defeat. The insurer will likely assert a lien on any recovery from those companies.

Evidence to protect right away

  • Photos and video of the machine, guards, warning labels and controls
  • The make, model and serial number, and the name of any service company on stickers or logs
  • A written request that your employer preserve the machine and its maintenance and repair records
  • Names and phone numbers of witnesses
  • Any Cal/OSHA inspection or citation information; employers must report serious injuries to Cal/OSHA within 8 hours (tit. 8, §342)
  • Medical records and a log of your symptoms and missed work

Machines are often repaired, sold or scrapped soon after an accident. If the equipment is gone, a product case can become much harder to prove.

Frequently asked questions

Can I sue my employer for unsafe machinery?

Generally no. Workers’ comp is the exclusive remedy against your employer, with narrow exceptions such as the power press guard rule, an uninsured employer, or a willful physical assault. A serious and willful misconduct claim can increase your comp benefits instead.

Can I sue the company that made the machine?

Often, yes, if a defect in the machine’s design, manufacture or warnings caused your injury. Product claims depend heavily on the machine itself, so preserve it if you can.

Does suing a third party affect my workers’ comp?

Your comp benefits continue, but the insurer can generally be reimbursed from your recovery and may take a credit against future benefits. The cases should be handled together.

How long do I have to file a lawsuit?

Generally two years from the injury for a personal injury claim. If a public entity is involved, a written government claim is generally due within six months (Gov. Code §911.2). Workers’ comp has its own one-year deadline.

What if a coworker caused the accident?

Usually workers’ comp is your only remedy, unless the coworker willfully and without provocation physically attacked you or was intoxicated (Labor Code §3601).

Talk to a California workers’ comp lawyer

Employees First Labor Law represents workers exclusively in workers’ compensation and employment cases across California, and we review whether an outside party may also be responsible. We offer free virtual consultations. Contact us online or call (310) 853-3461.

This article is general information about California law as of 2026, not legal advice for your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

The Employees First Labor Law team

Free, confidential consultation

Talk to a lawyer who only works for employees.

Free virtual consultations, exclusively for workers. Tell us what happened at work. Se habla español.

Call (310) 853-3461Free case review
Employees First Labor Law
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.