Skip to content
¿Prefiere español?Empleados PrimeroAbogados Laborales
¿Prefiere español? Empleados Primero Abogados Laborales
EMPLOYEES FIRST LABOR LAW

Compensation Law

QME vs. AME in California Workers’ Comp: What’s the Difference?

A QME (Qualified Medical Evaluator) and an AME (Agreed Medical Evaluator) both resolve medical disputes in a California workers’ comp case, such as whether…

Reviewed by Jonathan P. LaCour, Esq. CEO · Senior Trial Counsel

Updated 5 min read

In this guide10 sections
  1. Key takeaways
  2. QME and AME at a glance
  3. What these evaluators decide
  4. How the QME process works
  5. Why some cases use an AME
  6. A hypothetical example
  7. Preparing for the evaluation
  8. Deadlines to watch
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Talk to a California workers’ comp lawyer

A QME (Qualified Medical Evaluator) and an AME (Agreed Medical Evaluator) both resolve medical disputes in a California workers’ comp case, such as whether your injury is work-related, your work restrictions, and your permanent disability. The difference is how the doctor is chosen. A QME comes from a random panel of three doctors issued by the state, while an AME is a doctor you and the insurer agree on, and only workers who have a lawyer can use an AME.

Key takeaways

  • QMEs are state-certified doctors assigned through a three-doctor panel from the DWC Medical Unit; AMEs are chosen by agreement of both sides.
  • If you don’t have a lawyer, you can use only a panel QME; the employer may not seek your agreement to an AME (Labor Code §4062.1).
  • If you have a lawyer, each side strikes one name from the QME panel, or the parties can agree on an AME at any time (Labor Code §4062.2).
  • Evaluation reports are generally due within 30 days after the exam (8 CCR §38), and the employer pays for the evaluation (Labor Code §4064).
  • Deadlines to object to your treating doctor’s report are short: 20 days if you have a lawyer, 30 days if you don’t (Labor Code §4062(a)).

QME and AME at a glance

QMEAME
How chosenRandom panel of three from the DWC; the specialty is requested by a partyAgreed on by your lawyer and the insurer
Who can useRepresented and unrepresented workersRepresented workers only
Choosing the doctorUnrepresented: you pick one of the three. Represented: each side strikes one, and the remaining doctor is the QMEAny doctor both sides accept, often a specialist with a long track record
Who paysEmployer or insurerEmployer or insurer
Report deadlineGenerally 30 days after the exam, with limited extensionsSame
Challenging the opinionPossible, but you need a medical or legal basisHarder, because you agreed to the doctor

What these evaluators decide

QMEs and AMEs are medical-legal evaluators. They don’t treat you. They examine you, review your records and write a report the judge and the parties rely on for disputed issues such as:

  • Whether the injury arose out of and in the course of employment (Labor Code §4060)
  • Whether you’re permanent and stationary, your permanent impairment and need for future medical care (Labor Code §4061)
  • Your work status and restrictions, and other medical disputes with your treating doctor’s findings (Labor Code §4062)
  • Apportionment between your work injury and other causes

They don’t decide whether a specific treatment request should be approved. Treatment denials made through utilization review go to Independent Medical Review instead. See how IMR differs from a QME.

How the QME process works

If you don’t have a lawyer

  1. A dispute arises, for example the insurer denies your claim or you or the insurer object to your treating doctor’s report within 30 days.
  2. A panel request is submitted on the DWC’s form. The requesting party designates the specialty.
  3. The DWC Medical Unit issues a panel of three QMEs.
  4. You choose one, schedule the appointment and tell the claims administrator within 10 days of the panel being issued. If you don’t, the employer may choose the QME.

More detail is in our guide to the QME process for unrepresented workers.

If you have a lawyer

  1. Your lawyer or the insurer objects to the treating doctor’s report within 20 days, or a compensability dispute arises.
  2. The parties may try to agree on an AME. If they don’t, either side can request a panel online once the waiting period after the objection has passed.
  3. Each side strikes one name within 10 days of the panel being issued; if a party doesn’t strike, the other side may select the QME.
  4. The remaining doctor serves as the QME.

See the QME process for represented workers, and our tips on how to choose the right QME.

Why some cases use an AME

An AME can be a good fit when both sides want a particular specialist, or when they want to avoid the delay and randomness of a panel. Because both sides chose the doctor, the AME’s report tends to carry real weight, and it can be difficult for either side to move away from it later. That cuts both ways: a favorable AME report is strong, and an unfavorable one is hard to overcome.

That’s why lawyers agree to an AME only after researching the doctor’s reporting history and how the doctor has handled similar injuries. If you don’t have a lawyer, the law doesn’t allow the employer to ask you to agree on an AME.

A hypothetical example

Elena hurts her wrist on an assembly line. Her treating doctor says she can’t use her right hand. The insurer objects and wants a QME. Elena, without a lawyer, requests an orthopedic panel, picks the hand specialist on the list and schedules within 10 days. If Elena later hires a lawyer and the insurer suggests an AME, her lawyer would look at the proposed doctor’s past reports before agreeing. If the parties can’t agree, Elena keeps the panel process.

Preparing for the evaluation

  • Bring a list of your symptoms, the activities you can’t do, and your medications.
  • Describe how the injury happened and any prior injuries honestly; inconsistencies can undermine your credibility.
  • Don’t exaggerate or downplay your pain.
  • Write down how long the exam lasted and what the doctor did.
  • Get a copy of the report when it is served and read it carefully.

If the report has errors or ignores evidence, there are ways to respond, such as asking for a supplemental report or questioning the evaluator. See how to dispute a QME or AME report.

Deadlines to watch

StepDeadlineLaw
Object to treating doctor’s report20 days if represented; 30 days if notLabor Code §4062(a)
Unrepresented worker selects and schedules QME10 days after the panel issuesLabor Code §4062.1
Each side strikes a name (represented)10 days after the panel issuesLabor Code §4062.2
QME or AME reportGenerally 30 days after the exam8 CCR §38

Frequently asked questions

Is an AME better than a QME?

Not automatically. An AME gives both sides a say in the doctor, but you’re bound to a doctor you agreed to. A panel QME is random but available to everyone. The right choice depends on the doctors involved and your medical issues.

Can I use an AME without a lawyer?

No. If you don’t have a lawyer, disputes go through a panel QME, and the employer may not seek your agreement to an AME.

Who pays for the QME or AME?

The employer or its insurer pays for medical-legal evaluations obtained through the QME or AME process (Labor Code §4064).

Is the QME my doctor?

No. A QME evaluates disputed issues and writes a report. Your treating doctor continues to manage your care.

Can I change my QME?

Only in limited situations, such as certain procedural problems with the panel. Disagreeing with the report isn’t enough by itself, though there are ways to challenge a report.

Talk to a California workers’ comp lawyer

Employees First Labor Law represents workers exclusively, including injured workers facing QME and AME evaluations. We offer free virtual consultations. Contact us online or call (310) 853-3461. The DWC’s Information and Assistance Unit can also explain the QME forms for free.

This article is general information about California law as of 2026, not legal advice for your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

The Employees First Labor Law team

Free, confidential consultation

Talk to a lawyer who only works for employees.

Free virtual consultations, exclusively for workers. Tell us what happened at work. Se habla español.

Call (310) 853-3461Free case review
Employees First Labor Law
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.