What Can a Former Employer Say About You in a Reference?

In California, a former employer can generally tell a prospective employer the truth about your job performance and qualifications, but it cannot lie about you, cannot try to keep you from getting hired through misrepresentations, and cannot give a bad reference to retaliate against you. No law requires your former employer to say anything at all, and many will only confirm your dates of employment and job title.

The difference between a lawful reference and an illegal one can decide whether you get your next job. A false statement that you were fired for stealing, or a manager who tells callers you “sued us,” can cost you offer after offer. California law gives you tools to fight back, including treble damages for blacklisting.

This guide explains what an employer may lawfully say, where references cross into defamation, blacklisting or retaliation, how to find out what is being said, how to protect your reference when you leave, and the deadlines to act.

No law requires a reference

California does not require private employers to give references. Many companies have a “neutral reference” policy: they confirm only your dates of employment and job title, and sometimes your final pay if you authorize it. These policies exist mainly to protect employers from the legal risks this article describes.

A neutral reference is not a bad sign. Prospective employers are used to it. What matters is whether your former employer, or a manager acting outside the policy, is saying something false or saying it for an unlawful reason.

Keep in mind that a prospective employer in California generally cannot ask you about your salary history (Labor Code 432.3). That rule applies to the new employer’s questions to you, but it is worth knowing if a reference conversation drifts into what you used to earn.

Key fact

What a former employer can legally say

Civil Code 47(c) gives employers a qualified privilege for references. A current or former employer is protected when it communicates about your job performance or qualifications to a prospective employer if the statement is:

• Based on credible evidence;
• Made without malice; and
• Made to, and at the request of, the prospective employer.

The same subsection allows an employer to say, without malice, whether it would rehire you and whether a decision not to rehire is based on a determination that you engaged in sexual harassment.

So an employer can usually say, truthfully, that you were fired, that you missed sales targets, or that it would not rehire you. The privilege is “qualified” because it disappears if the employer acted with malice, such as knowing the statement was false or making it with reckless disregard for the truth, or out of hatred or ill will.

---

Where a reference crosses the line

What the former employer says or does	Generally lawful?	Law
Confirms dates, title and pay (with your consent)	Yes	Civil Code 47(c)
Truthfully says you were fired, or would not be rehired	Yes	Civil Code 47(c); Labor Code 1053
Falsely says you stole, were violent or were fired for cause	No	Defamation: Civil Code 45, 46
Uses misrepresentations to keep you from being hired	No	Labor Code 1050, 1054
Mentions that you complained, took leave or filed a claim, to discourage hiring	No	Gov. Code 12940(h); Labor Code 98.6, 1102.5
Shares your medical information without authorization	No	Civil Code 56.20

Defamation

Defamation is a false statement of fact, communicated to someone else, that is not privileged and that harms your reputation. Statements that injure you in your trade or profession, like falsely saying you were fired for theft, are treated as especially harmful under Civil Code 45 and 46. Opinions (“not a team player”) are harder to challenge than false facts (“was caught falsifying time records”), and truth is a complete defense.

Blacklisting under Labor Code 1050–1054

Labor Code 1050 makes it a misdemeanor for an employer, after discharging an employee, to prevent or attempt to prevent that person from getting other work through misrepresentation. Labor Code 1052 extends this to anyone who knowingly causes, allows or helps with a violation.

Labor Code 1053 draws the boundary: an employer may give a truthful statement of the reason for a discharge, or why an employee left, when asked. The line is between telling the truth on request and spreading falsehoods to keep you out of work.

The civil remedy is powerful. Labor Code 1054 lets the worker sue for treble damages, three times the actual harm.

💡 Example: Jordan was fired from a property management company. Two offers were withdrawn after reference checks. A professional reference-checking service records his old manager falsely telling a caller that Jordan “was let go for taking cash from tenants.” Jordan lost $15,000 in wages before he found another job. If he proves blacklisting under Labor Code 1050, treble damages could reach 3 × $15,000 = $45,000, in addition to any defamation damages.

---

Bad references as retaliation

Retaliation laws protect you after you leave. The U.S. Supreme Court held in Robinson v. Shell Oil Co. (1997) 519 U.S. 337 that federal anti-retaliation law covers former employees, and California’s laws are generally read at least as broadly. Under FEHA (Gov. Code 12940(h)), an employer cannot retaliate against you for opposing discrimination or harassment, filing a complaint, or taking part in an investigation. Labor Code 98.6 and 1102.5 protect you for complaining about wages or reporting violations of law.

A bad or false reference given because you complained, filed a CRD complaint, sued, filed a wage claim or a workers’ comp claim, or took protected leave can be retaliation. Timing and the content of the reference are key evidence: a manager who mentions your lawsuit or complaint to a prospective employer is handing you proof. See our guide on being fired after complaining to HR.

By the numbers30 days

How to find out what is being said

You usually do not hear a reference directly, so you may need to work to find out what is said:

• Ask the prospective employer. If an offer is withdrawn, politely ask whether something in a reference check caused it.
• Use a professional reference-checking service. These services contact your former employer and document what is said. A recorded or documented statement is far more useful than a friend’s informal call.
• Request your personnel file. Under Labor Code 1198.5, current and former employees can ask in writing to inspect or copy their personnel records, and the employer must comply within 30 days. You can also request your payroll records (Labor Code 226) and copies of anything you signed (Labor Code 432).
• Check your separation paperwork. How your departure was recorded often predicts what is said.

Do not secretly record phone calls yourself. California generally requires consent of all parties to record a confidential conversation (Penal Code 632).

---

Protecting your reference when you leave

The best time to manage your reference is before you sign anything on the way out. If you are offered a severance agreement, you can negotiate for:

• An agreed neutral reference that confirms only dates and title, with reference calls routed to HR;
• A written reference letter with agreed language;
• Your departure characterized as a resignation;
• A commitment that named managers will not comment.

Our guide to reviewing a severance agreement explains how to ask. Outside of severance, line up other references, such as former supervisors who have moved on, clients or coworkers, so a prospective employer does not rely on one source.

---

Deadlines to act

• Defamation: generally 1 year from the statement (Code Civ. Proc. 340(c)).
• FEHA retaliation: generally 3 years to file with the Civil Rights Department, then 1 year to sue after a right-to-sue notice.
• Labor Code 98.6 retaliation complaint to the Labor Commissioner: generally 1 year.
• Whistleblower retaliation under Labor Code 1102.5: generally 3 years in court.

Because the defamation deadline is short and each new statement can be a new claim, write down every lost offer and every reference you learn about as it happens.

---

What to do if a former employer is hurting your job search

1. Document each lost opportunity: the company, the position, the date, who told you what, and any written withdrawal.
2. Request your personnel file and payroll records in writing and keep a copy of your request.
3. Consider a professional reference check to document what is actually said.
4. Do not confront your former manager or post about it online, which can create new problems.
5. Talk to an employment lawyer. A letter from a lawyer citing Civil Code 47(c) and Labor Code 1050 often stops the problem quickly, and you may have claims for the jobs you lost.

---

Frequently asked questions

Can my former employer say I was fired?

Yes, if it is true and said without malice. It cannot say you were fired for a reason that is false.

Can my former employer tell people I sued or filed a complaint?

Doing so to discourage a new employer from hiring you can be illegal retaliation. A reference that mentions your complaint or lawsuit is strong evidence of a retaliatory motive.

Can they say I am not eligible for rehire?

Generally yes. Civil Code 47(c) expressly allows an employer to say, without malice, whether it would rehire you.

Can my former employer share my medical information?

Generally no. California’s Confidentiality of Medical Information Act limits an employer’s use and disclosure of employee medical information without written authorization (Civil Code 56.20).

What if my former boss is badmouthing me personally, not through HR?

Managers and other individuals can be liable for their own defamatory statements. The same rules apply whether the statement comes from HR or a former supervisor speaking informally.

---