- Home
- Sexual Harassment
- Gov. Code §12923
Government Code §12923: how California judges harassment
Government Code 12923 is the Legislature's instruction to courts on harassment cases. One incident can be enough, an offhand remark can matter, and these cases are rarely meant to be decided by a judge before trial.
- Exclusively for workers
- Free virtual consultations
- Your consultation is confidential
Government Code §12923 tells California courts how to apply the state's workplace harassment laws. In effect since January 1, 2019, it says a single incident can be enough to reach trial, you don't have to show your productivity dropped, offhand remarks can be evidence, the sexual harassment standard doesn't change by type of workplace, and harassment cases are rarely right for summary judgment.
On this page
- What Government Code 12923 is, and why it exists
- Which part of §12923 fits your situation? Tap…
- Government Code 12923(a) to (c), in plain words
- §12923(d) and (e): every workplace, and the role…
- What §12923 tells courts to weigh, and what it…
- How §12923 fits with the rest of FEHA
- Questions about Government Code 12923
- Keep reading
§ 01
What Government Code 12923 is, and why it exists
California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) makes it unlawful to harass a worker because of sex, gender, race, disability or another protected trait. The ban itself is in Government Code §12940(j), which our §12940 explainer covers. Section 12923 does something different. It doesn't create a new claim. It tells judges how to read the harassment rules that already exist.
The section opens with these words: "The Legislature hereby declares its intent with regard to application of the laws about harassment contained in this part." It was added by Senate Bill 1300 in 2018 and took effect on January 1, 2019.
Why did lawmakers write it? The section answers arguments the Legislature disagreed with: that one incident is never enough, that an isolated comment is only a "stray remark", and that crude talk is normal in certain kinds of jobs. It names the court decisions it rejects and sets out the approach it wants courts to use instead.
Most of the section applies to harassment on any basis FEHA protects. One subdivision, (d), is about sexual harassment at work specifically. If your question is practical, such as "is what happened to me harassment?", start with our two-minute harassment check or our guide to whether one incident can be sexual harassment. This page explains the statute itself.
§ 02
Which part of §12923 fits your situation? Tap what fits
Employers often raise the same few arguments. Each one is answered by a different part of the statute.
Subdivision (b): a single incident
Section 12923(b) says "a single incident of harassing conduct is sufficient to create a triable issue" about a hostile work environment if it unreasonably interfered with your work or created an intimidating, hostile or offensive working environment. That means one serious incident can be enough for a case to go to trial. It isn't a promise of how a case ends.
Can one incident be sexual harassment?Subdivision (a): no need to show your productivity dropped
You don't have to prove your productivity dropped. Section 12923(a) says it is enough to show that a reasonable person in your position would find, as you did, that the harassment "so altered working conditions as to make it more difficult to do the job." Pushing through and still doing good work doesn't mean the harassment didn't matter.
Subdivision (c): stray remarks
Section 12923(c) says a hostile work environment depends on "the totality of the circumstances". It also says a discriminatory remark can be relevant evidence even if it wasn't made during a job decision, or was made by someone who doesn't make decisions. The Legislature affirmed the California Supreme Court's rejection of the "stray remarks doctrine" in Reid v. Google (2010).
Sexual comments and jokes at workSubdivision (d): same standard in every workplace
"The legal standard for sexual harassment should not vary by type of workplace." It doesn't matter that an occupation once had more sexual talk or conduct. Courts should consider the nature of the workplace only when engaging in or witnessing sexual conduct and commentary is integral to the job duties. A kitchen, warehouse or sales floor doesn't get a lower standard.
Sexual harassment of restaurant and bar workersSubdivision (e): summary judgment
Summary judgment is when a judge ends a case before trial because there is nothing for a jury to decide. Section 12923(e) says "harassment cases are rarely appropriate for disposition on summary judgment", because they involve questions that are "not determinable on paper." Judges still decide these motions case by case.
§ 03
Government Code 12923(a) to (c), in plain words
(a) What harassment does, and what you have to show
The purpose of these laws, the statute says, is "to provide all Californians with an equal opportunity to succeed in the workplace." It declares that harassment creates a hostile, offensive, oppressive or intimidating work environment when it "sufficiently offends, humiliates, distresses, or intrudes upon its victim" so as to disrupt the person's emotional tranquility at work, affect their ability to do the job as usual, or otherwise undermine their sense of well-being.
Subdivision (a) approves the standard set out by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in her concurring opinion in the U.S. Supreme Court case Harris v. Forklift Systems (1993). Under it, "the plaintiff need not prove that his or her tangible productivity has declined." It is enough that a reasonable person would find, as you did, that the harassment made the job more difficult to do.
(b) A single incident
One incident of harassing conduct can be enough to create a "triable issue", meaning enough for a jury to decide, if it unreasonably interfered with your work performance or created an intimidating, hostile or offensive working environment. The Legislature rejected the federal appeals court decision in Brooks v. City of San Mateo (2000) and said it "shall not be used" to decide what conduct is severe or pervasive enough to violate FEHA.
(c) The whole picture, including "stray" remarks
Whether a work environment was hostile "depends upon the totality of the circumstances." Courts look at everything together, not each incident on its own. A discriminatory remark "may be relevant, circumstantial evidence of discrimination" even if it wasn't made in connection with a job decision or was said by someone who doesn't make decisions. The statute affirms Reid v. Google, Inc. (2010) and its rejection of the "stray remarks doctrine", the idea that isolated comments can be ignored.
§ 04
§12923(d) and (e): every workplace, and the role of the jury
(d) No lower standard for "rough" workplaces
Subdivision (d) is the one written about sexual harassment specifically. It begins: "The legal standard for sexual harassment should not vary by type of workplace." It is "irrelevant that a particular occupation may have been characterized by a greater frequency of sexually related commentary or conduct in the past."
There is one narrow exception. Courts should consider the nature of the workplace "only" when "engaging in or witnessing prurient conduct and commentary is integral to the performance of the job duties." In plain words, that is a job where sexual content is part of the work itself. It does not cover a job just because coworkers there tend to talk that way. The Legislature disapproved any contrary reasoning in Kelley v. Conco Companies (2011), a California Court of Appeal decision.
(e) Harassment cases belong with a jury, not "on paper"
"Harassment cases are rarely appropriate for disposition on summary judgment." The statute affirms Nazir v. United Airlines, Inc. (2009) and its observation that hostile work environment cases involve issues "not determinable on paper." Whether conduct was unwelcome, how serious it was, and how it affected you often turn on who is believed, which is usually for a jury to decide.
This matters because employers often ask the court to end a case before trial. Subdivision (e) tells judges to be cautious about doing that. It doesn't forbid summary judgment, and it doesn't decide any case.
§ 05
What §12923 tells courts to weigh, and what it rejects
A side-by-side summary of the statute's five subdivisions.
What courts should consider
- Whether a reasonable person would find, as you did, that the harassment made the job more difficult to do.
- Whether one incident unreasonably interfered with your work or created an intimidating, hostile or offensive environment.
- The totality of the circumstances: every incident and remark together.
- Discriminatory remarks, even from someone who doesn't make job decisions.
- The same standard for sexual harassment in every type of workplace.
- That harassment cases usually need a trial, not a decision on paper.
What the Legislature rejected
- A requirement that your productivity actually declined.
- Using Brooks v. City of San Mateo (2000) to decide what is severe or pervasive under FEHA.
- The "stray remarks doctrine", which treated isolated comments as irrelevant.
- The idea that a job with a history of sexual talk gets a lower standard.
- Reasoning to the contrary in Kelley v. Conco Companies (2011).
- Routinely ending harassment cases on summary judgment.
§ 07
Questions about Government Code 12923
Can I sue under Government Code §12923?
Not on its own. Section 12923 is a statement of how the Legislature wants harassment laws applied. A harassment claim is brought under Government Code §12940(j), and §12923 guides how a court evaluates it.
Does §12923 apply only to sexual harassment?
No. Subdivisions (a), (b), (c) and (e) speak about harassment generally, so they apply to harassment based on any trait FEHA protects. Subdivision (d) is written about sexual harassment.
What does "triable issue" mean?
It means there is a real factual dispute for a jury to decide, so a judge shouldn't end the case before trial. It doesn't mean the case will win.
Does §12923 get rid of the "severe or pervasive" test?
No. Harassment under FEHA still has to be severe or pervasive enough to create a hostile work environment. Section 12923 explains how to apply that test: one incident can be enough, every incident counts together, and your productivity doesn't have to drop.
When did §12923 take effect?
January 1, 2019. It was added by Senate Bill 1300, signed in 2018.
Does §12923 change the deadline to file?
No. A complaint with the Civil Rights Department generally must be filed within three years of the unlawful practice, and a lawsuit generally within one year after the right-to-sue notice. See our statute of limitations guide.
§ 08
Keep reading
Sources
- Gov. Code §12923 (legislative declarations on harassment)
- Gov. Code §12940 (FEHA unlawful practices)
- Gov. Code §12960 (CRD complaint deadlines)
- Gov. Code §12965 (right-to-sue notice)
- SB 1300 (2018), Stats. 2018, ch. 955
- California Civil Rights Department: employment
This page is general information about California law, not legal advice for your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change; this page was last updated November 2026.
Tell us what happened. We will listen.
Free virtual consultations, exclusively for workers. Your consultation is confidential.
We work on contingency: our fee is a percentage of what we recover for you. How case costs are handled is spelled out in your written fee agreement.Free Case Consultation
Tell us what happened. Free virtual consultations, exclusively for workers, in English or Spanish.