Skip to content
¿Prefiere español?Empleados PrimeroAbogados Laborales
¿Prefiere español? Empleados Primero Abogados Laborales
EMPLOYEES FIRST LABOR LAW

Compensation Law

What Is an Independent Medical Review (IMR) in Workers’ Comp?

Independent Medical Review (IMR) is how you challenge a California workers’ comp utilization review (UR) decision that denied, delayed or modified treatment your doctor…

Reviewed by Jonathan P. LaCour, Esq. CEO · Senior Trial Counsel

Updated 6 min read

In this guide9 sections
  1. Key takeaways
  2. When IMR applies
  3. IMR deadlines and timelines
  4. How to request IMR, step by step
  5. How to improve your chances
  6. A hypothetical example
  7. If IMR upholds the denial
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Talk to a California workers’ comp lawyer

Independent Medical Review (IMR) is how you challenge a California workers’ comp utilization review (UR) decision that denied, delayed or modified treatment your doctor requested. An independent physician reviewer, working through the state’s contractor Maximus, reads your records and decides whether the treatment is medically necessary. You generally must request IMR within 30 days of service of the UR decision, and the employer pays the cost. The odds are difficult, so a well-documented application matters.

Key takeaways

  • IMR is the only way to challenge a UR denial or modification based on medical necessity (Labor Code §§4062(a), 4610.5).
  • Deadline: 30 days from service of the UR decision, or 10 days for drug formulary disputes. The UR letter includes the application and the deadline.
  • The reviewer doesn’t examine you. Decisions are generally due within 30 days, or 3 days for expedited review (5 working days for formulary drugs).
  • In 2025, according to the state, IMR overturned treatment denials at an overall rate of 10.2%, so strong supporting records from your doctor are essential.
  • An IMR decision is binding and can be appealed to the WCAB within 30 days only on narrow grounds.

When IMR applies

IMR is for disputes over “disputed medical treatment,” which Labor Code §4610.5(c) defines as treatment that a UR decision modified or denied on the basis of medical necessity. Examples include a denied surgery, MRI, injection, medication, psychological treatment or a cut in physical therapy visits. Read our guide to utilization review for how those decisions are made.

IMR generally doesn’t apply when:

  • The insurer denies your whole claim. According to the DWC’s IMR page, IMR is not available while liability is disputed. One exception: for a claim still under investigation without a denial, IMR is available within the first 90 days for treatment costs up to $10,000.
  • UR missed its deadline. A 2014 en banc decision of the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board held that an untimely UR decision is invalid and not subject to IMR. The board decides medical necessity instead.
  • The dispute is about disability, work status or causation. Those issues go to a Qualified Medical Evaluator or Agreed Medical Evaluator. See the difference between IMR and a QME.
  • You’re disputing an MPN doctor’s diagnosis or treatment plan. That uses the medical provider network’s second-opinion, third-opinion and MPN IMR process, which is separate.

IMR deadlines and timelines

StepTimingSource
Request IMR (most treatment)30 days after service of the UR decisionLabor Code §4610.5(h)(1)
Request IMR (formulary drug dispute)10 days after service of the UR decisionLabor Code §4610.5(h)(1)
Liability also disputed when UR decided30 days after you’re notified the liability dispute was resolvedLabor Code §4610.5(h)(2)
IMR decision, regular reviewWithin 30 days of receiving the application and supporting documentsLabor Code §4610.6(d); DWC IMR FAQ
IMR decision, formulary drug disputeWithin 5 working daysLabor Code §4610.6(d)
IMR decision, expedited (treatment not yet given)Within 3 daysLabor Code §4610.6(d); DWC IMR FAQ
Insurer authorizes approved treatment not yet providedWithin 5 business daysDWC IMR FAQ
Appeal an IMR decision to the WCABWithin 30 days of the date the determination was mailedLabor Code §4610.6(h)

If the UR notice left out required IMR information, the 30-day clock doesn’t start until proper notice is given (Labor Code §4610.5(h)(3)).

How to request IMR, step by step

  1. Find the IMR application in your UR denial. The written UR decision must tell you it’s final unless you request IMR, and must include the one-page application (Labor Code §4610.5(f)). The DWC warns against using a modified or self-made form.
  2. Fill it out and sign it. Mark standard or expedited review. Expedited review requires your treating physician’s certification that you face an imminent and serious threat to your health.
  3. Attach the complete UR decision. If someone is representing you, include the designated representative form.
  4. Send it on time. The DWC’s IMR FAQ directs applications to DWC – IMR, c/o Maximus Federal Services, Inc., PO Box 138009, Sacramento, CA 95813-8009. Keep proof of the date you sent it.
  5. Send supporting records. You or your designee may send Maximus records that support the treatment, such as your doctor’s recommendation and new medical records, with a copy to the claims administrator at the same time. The claims administrator must also send your records once the case is assigned.

How to improve your chances

The state reported that in 2025 IMR received 201,037 applications and overturned treatment denials at an overall rate of 10.2%, down from 12.7% in 2024 (DIR news release). Most denials are upheld, which is why preparation matters.

  • Match the request to the guidelines. IMR reviewers apply the Medical Treatment Utilization Schedule (MTUS). Ask your doctor to explain how the treatment meets it, or why your case calls for something different, citing medical evidence.
  • Document what has already failed. Many guidelines require conservative care first. Records showing you completed therapy, medication or injections without enough relief can be decisive.
  • Fill the gaps UR identified. If UR said a record was missing, such as imaging or a functional assessment, send it.
  • Don’t wait for the deadline. File early so there’s time to gather records.

A hypothetical example

Daniel, a warehouse forklift operator, has knee pain after a fall at work. His doctor requests arthroscopic surgery, and UR denies it, saying the records don’t show a trial of physical therapy. Daniel actually completed eight weeks of therapy at a different clinic, but those notes never reached the reviewer.

Daniel files the IMR application within 30 days and sends Maximus the therapy notes and his doctor’s report explaining why surgery is now appropriate, copying the insurer. Whether IMR approves the surgery depends on the medical evidence, but the missing records no longer stand in the way.

If IMR upholds the denial

An IMR decision is presumed correct and binding. Under Labor Code §4610.6(h), you can appeal to the WCAB within 30 days, but only by clear and convincing evidence of one of these grounds:

  • The administrative director acted without or beyond its powers
  • The decision was procured by fraud
  • The reviewer had a material conflict of interest
  • The decision resulted from bias based on a protected characteristic such as race, religion, age, sex or disability
  • The decision rests on a plainly erroneous finding of fact that is a matter of ordinary knowledge, not expert opinion

If an appeal succeeds, the dispute goes back for a new review by a different reviewer or organization; the judge can’t decide medical necessity directly (Labor Code §4610.6(i)). Disagreeing with the medical judgment isn’t enough to win an appeal. More often, the practical route is for your doctor to submit a new request supported by a documented change in your condition or new evidence. Under Labor Code §4610(k), a UR denial generally stays in effect for 12 months for the same treatment from the same doctor unless the facts change. See how to get treatment approved for more strategies.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to pay for IMR?

No. The DWC states that the costs of IMR are paid by employers.

Will the IMR doctor examine me?

No. The reviewer decides based on the records submitted and doesn’t perform a physical exam, which is why complete records matter.

Can I request IMR online?

The statute allows electronic requests, but the DWC’s current instructions direct applicants to mail the IMR form to Maximus. Follow the instructions in your UR letter and on the DWC website.

What happens if IMR approves my treatment?

The claims administrator must promptly implement the decision unless it disputes liability on another basis or appeals. According to the DWC, treatment not yet provided must be authorized within five business days.

Can my doctor help with the IMR?

Yes. The requesting physician may join or assist with your request and advocate for the treatment, and you can authorize a relative or other designee to help.

Talk to a California workers’ comp lawyer

Employees First Labor Law represents workers exclusively, including injured workers fighting treatment denials. We offer free virtual consultations to review your UR decision, deadlines and records. Contact us online or call (310) 853-3461.

This article is general information about California law as of 2026, not legal advice for your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

The Employees First Labor Law team

Free, confidential consultation

Talk to a lawyer who only works for employees.

Free virtual consultations, exclusively for workers. Tell us what happened at work. Se habla español.

Call (310) 853-3461Free case review
Employees First Labor Law
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.